Megrahi mistake?
04/09/2009
Top QC questions why second appeal wasn't brought forward
One of
Leading QC Michael Mansfield – who previously represented the Birmingham Six and the Guildford Four - told the Big Issue the Scottish Government was right to release al-Megrahi, but said there were still unanswered legal questions over its handling by the SNP government.
He said: “Of course there is room for compassion within the justice system. I’m sympathetic, the guy has prostrate cancer and he’s about to die, so I don’t have a problem with letting him out. What I have problem with is that there was a way of doing it that would have avoided all the pitfalls.”
Mansfield, who sat in on al-Megrahi’s first appeal in 2002 and was mooted as part of his defence team, said he is left wondering why the Scottish Government did not bring forward al-Megrahi’s second appeal which had been pending since 2006 and base their decision on its outcome. “That way the court decides whether the conviction is reliable or not,” he explained.
“The court either upholds the conviction, in which case the Scottish Government could have transferred him as a convicted prisoner to a prison in
Megrahi, 57, who is terminally ill, was freed last week by Scottish Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill. He had been given a life sentence for killing 270 people in the 1988 Pan Am Flight 103 bombing and had served eight years of his sentence. He has always maintained his innocence.
Al-Megrahi’s first appeal was turned down in 2002 and he lodged a second appeal in 2004. That was due to begin two years later but delays have meant that by the time of his release this month, no appeal had been heard.
Loading...
More News...
Nobel Laureate tackles Big Issues
Justice, poverty and philosophy on the agenda at Book Festival talk
Sir Alex pays tribute to friend and "great Govan man"
Manchester United legend honours the late Jimmy Reid
Free festival for Big Issue vendors
Universal Arts give magazine sellers free tickets for shows
Scots urged to dig deep for Pakistan flood victims
Aid agencies pooling resources to launch fundraising appeal
Health gap between rich and poor getting wider
Inequality at record high and set to get worse, say researchers
Housing benefit cuts will create 'ghettos'
Coalition government warned 200,000 people at risk of homelessness
Demand grows for 'living wage'
Cuts will not stop efforts to end in-work poverty, say campaigners
Competition Winner
The five lucky winners of the SimplyLive.com Kiss USB Stick competition are: Mr Luke Smith, Swansea; Joe Thomas, Southampton; Alister Strachan, Inverurie; Andrew Robinson, Dundee; Agnes Carmichael, Bellshill










Share this on